Availability and Validity - Network Topology
This Request for Proposals is closed, meaning we are not looking for any more proposals on this topic at the moment.
- Status: Closed, since research is outdated
- Proposer: @infinity0, @skalman, @mmagician
Project Description 📄
A part of the promise of Polkadot is to bring scalability to the blockchains. The way it achieves it is via delegating application-specific logic from layer 0 (the relay chain) to layer 1 chains (parachains). In order to achieve this efficiently yet securely, each parachain has its own block production mechanism (achieving efficient block production), but the finalisation of candidate parachain blocks still happens with the involvement of the relay chain validators.
The full mechanism is described in the host specification. In short, it is split into two parts: first, a publicly known subset of validators attests that the parachain block data is available to them (i.e., they must have it in their local storage); second, once 2/3+ of the first group have published their availability votes, a "secret" (VRF-based assignment) subset of validators checks the validity of the candidate, by checking its state transition against that parachain runtime, which is available on-(the relay)chain.
Currently, the gossip network among the relay chain validators does not make use of the public assignment of a the first subgroup of validators to a particular parachain. Instead, the candidate block is passed around the network until it reaches 2/3+ of approvals, causing an additional delay in the process of finalization of the candidate.
This proposal aims to solve this issue by creating a selective networking topology among the publicly known subset of validators assigned to a particular parachain ID. For full details of the topology and its considerations, please consult the Availability and Validity research document.
- Total Estimated Duration: 14 weeks
- Total Costs: 90,000 DAI
Milestone 1 - update & implementation plan
Given that the above linked research document was produced almost a year ago (at the time of writing the RFP) and the fast pace of polkadot development, especially parachain development, the first step should be related to understanding and updating, if necessary, that document.
understand what is the current implemention status for parachain networking in Polkadot
understand in depth what the new topology design tries to achieve
produce a write-up detailing the differences between current and proposed design
develop a roadmap for implementation, clearly identifying which parts of the codebase would be affected
Estimated Duration: 3 weeks
Costs: 15,000 DAI
Milestone 2 - Topology discovery by validators
As detailed in the Topology section, each validator should have a deterministic and equal view of the topology.
This milestone is tasked with figuring out the topology for each validator.
Note: The implementer might find that splitting Milestones 2 & 3 is counterproductive, and a more efficient approach is to actually combine these.
perform the calculation of correct network topology for each validator
add a method that returns the above result. This can either be an RPC method, thus allowing it to be verified externally, or an internal method, where the validators report (could be as simple as console logs) their assignment
run tests to verify the correctness of the calculation and unanimous consensus
Estimated Duration: 6 weeks
Costs: 30,000 DAI
Milestone 3 - Networking and benchmarking
This should be a "simple" milestone in that it replaces the previous mechanism for candidate block distribution (broadcast medium B) with direct links(D), as proposed in the Overview.
- Estimated Duration: 8 weeks
- Costs: 45,000 DAI
- apply the topology calculated
- distribute block data along the direct route
- perform an extensive testing & benchmarking exercise on a network with at least 20 validators. The parachain block production can be mocked.